Rolex Seadweller conundrum

[Tom-P]

Looks like the collective has spoken, and my old friend will be staying ... It is a nice one, and back on the wrist, thank for bringing me to my senses :)

Absolutely the right call. I dissent from many of the posts above in preferring the SD43 - bigger, but much better balanced in my view, less 'toppy' than the previous etc - but this is clearly the right outcome reading how you've described the watch.