First Porsche

[hogthrob]

Is it just me that thinks cross shopping a 911 and a Mscan is very odd? They are very different cars with very different use cases.

Head vs. heart.

[wileeeeeey]

Head vs. heart.

Was looking at macans the other day as my 911 fund is getting feasted on by everyone but me.

The boot space vs a Model Y seems minuscule if that’s a concern. Roughly 500L on the Macan and 850L on the Model Y. Killed it for me.

Really think the E43 estate could be the best of all worlds but it isn’t a Porsche.

[Chris_in_the_UK]

Was looking at macans the other day as my 911 fund is getting feasted on by everyone but me.

The boot space vs a Model Y seems minuscule if that’s a concern. Roughly 500L on the Macan and 850L on the Model Y. Killed it for me.

Really think the E43 estate could be the best of all worlds but it isn’t a Porsche.

It's not, but badge aside, there are plenty of decent boot space stuff that are equally entertaining. M5 touring as one example - personally I would go Alpina B5 Twin Turbo Touring.

[Stuno1]

Was looking at macans the other day as my 911 fund is getting feasted on by everyone but me.

The boot space vs a Model Y seems minuscule if that’s a concern. Roughly 500L on the Macan and 850L on the Model Y. Killed it for me.

Really think the E43 estate could be the best of all worlds but it isn’t a Porsche.

If I wanted a 911 I would never consider a Macan but again I guess it depends on your use case for the car. If I wanted a very practical fast car that handles well it would be Audi rs4/6.

[Hood]

If I wanted a 911 I would never consider a Macan but again I guess it depends on your use case for the car. If I wanted a very practical fast car that handles well it would be Audi rs4/6.

Fair point
The 911 on stilts statement about a Macan is bullshit.
Macan is an amazing car but it's not a sports car.
Never had an RS4 or RS6 but from what I've heard the RS4 doesn't have a lot of space.

[Stuno1]

Fair point
The 911 on stilts statement about a Macan is bullshit.
Macan is an amazing car but it's not a sports car.
Never had an RS4 or RS6 but from what I've heard the RS4 doesn't have a lot of space.

I have seen reviews and all say the same. The boot space off the rs4 is surprisingly small.