Of the newer fragrances, Christian Dior Elixir is superb and it gets me lots of compliments!
I have been trying out some of the Geo F Trumper scents and have found their products to be excellent. In particular:
Eucris - dark & masculine. James Bond pedigree
GFT - an excellent citrus scent with a burst of lemon to start with.
Sandalwood - I have tried a number of sandalwood scents (ToBS, Floris, etc) but have found this one to be the best.
Spanish Leather - Imperial leather in a bottle!
Different scents smell different on different people, - once you find a good one that suits you - and you'll know as you'll constantly get women telling you how nice you smell - stick with it - for me, it's been Davidoff Champion for years now, - hope they don't discontinue it!